Japan or South Korea · Five days, two cities, the same plan in each
There is no universal winner. Which country is easier depends first on your passport, then on what you want five days to hold. Below, the same two-city plan is laid out for both countries, with the official entry rules, train times, transfers and fares side by side.
Quick Verdict
| If this describes you | What the checked facts point to |
|---|---|
| Malaysian or Thai passport, short tourist trip | Japan needs no visa or pre-registration with an ICAO ePassport; Korea needs a K-ETA (₩10,000) before you fly, unless you are 17 or under or 65 or over. Thai passports: Japan allows 15 days, Korea 90. |
| Indonesian passport | Japan: 15 days without a visa once your ePassport is registered with a Japanese mission in Indonesia. Korea: a visa for an ordinary passport. |
| Philippine passport | Both need a visa for an ordinary passport. |
| US, Singapore or Australian passport | Both are visa-free for 90 days. Korea’s K-ETA exemption for these passports is set to end on 31 December 2026; nothing has been announced for 2027. |
| You are comparing published prices | Gyeongbokgung’s admission is lower than Nijo-jo’s, and the published KTX Seoul–Busan fare is lower than the Nozomi Shinagawa–Kyoto fare, at our exchange date. We could not confirm the fare from Yeongdeungpo, where our KTX starts. |
| You want the fewest changes with luggage | On this plan, Japan: one change in all between the airports and the hotels’ stations (none on arrival, one on departure), against three in Korea (one on arrival, two on departure). |
Entry Rules by Passport, Checked November 2026
These tables cover ordinary passports and short tourist visits only. Transit rules, Jeju Island’s own visa-free scheme and special visas are left out. Japan’s planned travel authorisation, JESTA, is described by Japan’s Immigration Services Agency as aimed for introduction during fiscal year 2028; it is not a requirement today.
Japan
| Passport | Visa · longest stay | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| Singapore | Not needed · 90 days | — |
| Malaysia | Not needed · 90 days | ICAO-compliant ePassport; Japan advises other passport holders to get a visa |
| Philippines | Needed | The visa sets the stay |
| United States | Not needed · 90 days | — |
| Australia | Not needed · 90 days | — |
| Thailand | Not needed · 15 days | ICAO-compliant ePassport; others need a visa in advance |
| Indonesia | Not needed · 15 days | ePassport registered with a Japanese mission in Indonesia (valid 3 years or to passport expiry) |
Source: Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, visa exemption and visa requirement pages, checked 3 November 2026.
South Korea
| Passport | Visa · longest stay | K-ETA |
|---|---|---|
| Singapore | Not needed · 90 days | Temporarily exempt to 31 Dec 2026 |
| Malaysia | Not needed · 3 months | Required, except ages 17 and under and 65 and over |
| Philippines | Needed for ordinary passports | Not applicable (visa) |
| United States | Not needed · 90 days | Temporarily exempt to 31 Dec 2026 |
| Australia | Not needed · 90 days | Temporarily exempt to 31 Dec 2026 |
| Thailand | Not needed · 90 days | Required, except ages 17 and under and 65 and over |
| Indonesia | Needed for ordinary passports | Not applicable (visa) |
Sources: K-ETA official site (eligible countries, the extension notice “effective until December 31, 2026 (KST)”, fee ₩10,000, exemption for ages 17 and under and 65 and over), Korea Tourism Organization, and the Korean Embassy’s visa-waiver table; checked 3 November 2026. We will recheck the K-ETA exemption on 30 December 2026.
Our country guides for Singapore, Thai, US and Australian travellers cover cards, phones and money once you are in Japan.
What Fits Into Five Days
To compare like with like, both plans use the same frame: arrive on Monday 7 December 2026 at 10:00, two nights in the first city, one fast train, two nights in the second city, and fly home from that second city on Friday 11 December at 18:00. Neither country has a public holiday that week. Each plan includes one paid historic site, chosen in advance: Nijo-jo in Kyoto and Gyeongbokgung in Seoul.
| Day | Japan | South Korea |
|---|---|---|
| Mon 7 Dec | Land at Haneda Terminal 3; Keikyu direct to Sengakuji, 16 min, no change; the hotel is by the station | Land at Incheon Terminal 1; AREX Express to Seoul Station, 43 min; Line 1 to Yeongdeungpo (no official journey time published). Gyeongbokgung is open today |
| Tue 8 Dec | Tokyo | Seoul. Gyeongbokgung is closed on Tuesdays |
| Wed 9 Dec | Nozomi 25: Shinagawa 10:37 → Kyoto 12:44. Nijo-jo is open | KTX 123: Yeongdeungpo 10:23 → Busan 13:35 |
| Thu 10 Dec | Kyoto | Busan |
| Fri 11 Dec | Subway Gojo → Kyoto (2 min), then HARUKA 25: Kyoto 12:00 → Kansai Airport 13:20 | Busan Station → Gimhae Airport by Line 1, Line 2 and the light rail, changing at Seomyeon and Sasang (no official journey time published) |
Train times are from the current official timetables: JR Central’s from 14 March 2026, JR West’s HARUKA timetable, and KORAIL’s KTX timetable as of 1 November 2026. Two Korean legs, Seoul Station to Yeongdeungpo and Busan Station to Gimhae Airport, have no published end-to-end time, so we have not claimed how long they take. For the Friday flight from Gimhae, leave Busan Station with time to spare for the two changes.
Transport Time, Transfers and Advance Bookings
| Leg | Japan | South Korea |
|---|---|---|
| Airport → first hotel’s station | 0 changes · 16 min | 1 change · 43 min to Seoul Station, then Line 1 |
| Fast train between cities | 0 changes · 2 h 07 min | 0 changes · 3 h 12 min |
| Second hotel → airport | 1 change · 2 min, then 80 min | 2 changes · no published total |
| Fast-train booking opens | Reserved seats one month ahead at 10:00; smart EX takes requests up to a year ahead | One month ahead at 07:00 |
| Airport-train booking | Keikyu: no reservation. HARUKA: from one month ahead | AREX Express: from two months ahead |
On this plan the Korean intercity ride is about an hour longer: the KTX from Yeongdeungpo runs 3 h 12 min, while a KTX from Seoul Station that morning (the KTX 27 at 10:28) reaches Busan at 13:14, in 2 h 46 min. On the Nozomi, a suitcase over 160 cm in total dimensions needs a seat with an oversized-baggage area, reserved in advance at no extra charge. For tickets, our JR Pass vs individual tickets guide explains when a pass pays off; for this route, Klook’s Tokyo–Kyoto shinkansen search shows the ticket options.
Transport and Sightseeing Costs, Line by Line
Fares and admissions are per adult, from the operators’ published prices; hotel prices are per room for two adults. Any dollar figures shown use the US Federal Reserve’s H.10 rates for 30 October 2026 (¥157.47 and ₩1,333.99 to the dollar). This is a conversion at one day’s published rate, not a price index or the rate your card will use.
| Item | Japan | South Korea |
|---|---|---|
| Airport train | Keikyu Haneda T3 → Sengakuji ¥330 ($2.10) | AREX Express ₩13,000 ($9.75) + Line 1 from ₩1,550 by transit card ($1.16; distance-based) |
| Fast train | Nozomi Shinagawa → Kyoto, reserved, off-peak ¥13,970 ($88.71) | KTX Seoul–Busan, standard ₩54,400 ($40.78), a reference fare for that city pair* |
| To the departure airport | Subway ¥220 ($1.40) + HARUKA reserved ¥3,590 ($22.80) | At most ₩1,800 by transit card ($1.35): Busan Metro (Lines 1 and 2, one fare) and the light rail each charge ₩1,600 or ₩1,800 by card, and a valid transfer between them costs only the higher fare |
| Paid historic site | Nijo-jo, castle and Ninomaru Palace ¥1,300 ($8.26) | Gyeongbokgung, foreign adults 19–64 ₩3,000 ($2.25) |
*KORAIL’s fare notice gives the Seoul–Busan fare from 1 September 2026; the Yeongdeungpo–Busan fare for the KTX 123 is not listed in the official sources we used. Nozomi off-peak applies to 9 December 2026 in JR Central’s season calendar; the regular-season fare is ¥14,170.
For hotels we tried to price the same chain on the same terms in all four cities: Toyoko Inn’s standard package with breakfast, the cheapest non-smoking double for two, non-member rate. On 3 November the Tokyo hotel we fixed in advance, by Shinagawa Station, had no room on that package for 7–9 December. When we checked again on 12 November it had one: a Premium Plus room with one 140 cm bed, a higher grade than the economy and mini doubles in the other three cities. Toyoko Inn’s prices exclude accommodation tax, and we could not confirm that tax for all four cities on the same basis, so we list the four prices without adding them up or ranking the countries on lodging. Tokyo and Kyoto each showed only one room left, so these prices can change quickly.
| Toyoko Inn (2 nights, 2 adults) | Price shown |
|---|---|
| Kyoto Gojo-karasuma, 9–11 Dec | ¥24,600 ($156.22) |
| Seoul Yeongdeungpo, 7–9 Dec | ₩184,000 ($137.93) |
| Busan Station No.1, 9–11 Dec | ₩168,000 ($125.94) |
| Tokyo Shinagawa-eki Takanawa-guchi, 7–9 Dec | ¥28,400 ($180.35), Premium Plus room |
Toyoko Inn official site, checked 12 November 2026 (the Kyoto, Seoul and Busan prices were the same on 3 November); shown prices include consumption tax and exclude accommodation tax. Dollar figures use the same 30 October 2026 Federal Reserve rates as the fare table.
Food and city transit are left out because there is no same-item price to compare. For a fuller picture of costs on the Japan side, see our Japan budget guide.
Which Destination Fits Which Traveler?
- Check your passport row first. For Malaysian and Thai passports, Japan has no K-ETA step, though a Thai ePassport gets 15 days in Japan against 90 in Korea. For Indonesian passports, Japan is visa-free once the ePassport is registered, while Korea needs a visa. For US, Singapore and Australian passports, both are open without a visa, and Korea’s K-ETA exemption is dated to 31 December 2026.
- Published prices go both ways. Gyeongbokgung costs $2.25 against Nijo-jo’s $8.26, the published Seoul–Busan KTX fare is $40.78 against $88.71 for the Nozomi from Shinagawa to Kyoto, and the rail ride to Gimhae Airport is cheaper than the HARUKA to Kansai. The train in from Haneda ($2.10) is cheaper than the AREX from Incheon ($9.75 before Line 1). The fare from Yeongdeungpo, where our KTX starts, is not confirmed.
- If you want fewer changes with bags, Japan’s plan has fewer. One change in all between the airports and the hotels’ stations (none on arrival, one on departure), against three in Korea (one on arrival, two on departure). Japan’s fast train is also about an hour shorter on these timetables.
- If you need to book far ahead, both open the fast train a month out. Japan’s smart EX accepts requests up to a year ahead; Korea’s AREX Express seats open two months ahead.
If Japan Fits You: APA Hotel Shinagawa Sengakuji Ekimae for the Tokyo Nights
For the two Tokyo nights on this plan (7–9 December 2026, two adults, one room), we set the conditions before looking at prices: within a 10-minute walk of Shinagawa Station by the hotel’s own access page, no meals, free cancellation, the general (not members-only) price, and the lowest total including taxes. We took the first three hotels in Booking.com’s default order for that search on 3 November, leaving out an ad, and priced the same three again on 12 November. I have not stayed at any of them; this is chosen from published prices and the hotels’ own access pages.
| Hotel | 2 nights, 2 adults · total |
|---|---|
| APA Hotel Shinagawa Sengakuji Ekimae | ¥37,260 including 10% consumption tax; Tokyo’s accommodation tax is ¥0 at this rate · Standard Double, non-smoking · free cancellation before 6 Dec |
| Shinagawa Tobu Hotel | ¥50,000 general price, shown as including taxes and charges (signed-in members see ¥36,000) · Small Double B, non-smoking · free cancellation before 4 Dec |
| Shinagawa Prince Hotel | ¥48,001; Booking.com notes that additional charges may apply · Main Tower Twin (6th–16th floor), non-smoking · free cancellation before 6 Dec |
Booking.com, prices from 12 November 2026 for 7–9 December 2026 (APA was also the lowest of the three on 3 November); APA’s breakdown read from the booking summary (“Includes ¥3,387 in taxes and charges … Excludes city tax”), and its one-night prices for the same room, ¥16,920 for 7 December and ¥20,340 for 8 December, put both nights below ¥10,000 per person before consumption tax. Tokyo’s accommodation tax is ¥0 below ¥10,000 per person per night, ¥100 from ¥10,000 and ¥200 from ¥15,000 (Tokyo Metropolitan Government). Prices change; check the live rate.
APA Hotel Shinagawa Sengakuji Ekimae had the lowest total of the three. It stands by Sengakuji Station, where Keikyu trains from Haneda Terminal 3 arrive directly in 16 minutes, and its own page puts Shinagawa Station’s Takanawa exit, for the Nozomi to Kyoto, 9 minutes away on foot. Check APA Hotel Shinagawa Sengakuji Ekimae’s live price for your dates on Booking.com, or compare other Tokyo stays on Agoda. For the Kyoto nights, compare Kyoto stays on Booking.com.
Japan or Korea: Questions
Is Japan or South Korea better for a 5-day trip?
Neither wins for everyone. On the same two-city plan, Japan’s had fewer changes between airports and hotels and a shorter fast train; Korea’s palace admission and its published Seoul–Busan fare were lower. Your passport may decide it first.
Do I need a K-ETA for South Korea?
It depends on your passport and age. Malaysian and Thai ordinary passports need one (₩10,000), unless you are 17 or under or 65 or over. US, Singapore and Australian passports are temporarily exempt until 31 December 2026, and Korea has not announced what happens after that. Philippine and Indonesian ordinary passports need a visa instead.
Do Malaysians need a visa for Japan?
No, with an ICAO-compliant ePassport, for up to 90 days. Japan’s foreign ministry advises holders of other passports to get a visa.
Is the KTX cheaper than the shinkansen?
For the two city pairs we checked, yes: KORAIL’s published Seoul–Busan fare is ₩54,400 ($40.78) and JR Central’s Shinagawa–Kyoto Nozomi fare is ¥13,970 off-peak ($88.71), at the 30 October 2026 Federal Reserve rates. Fares vary by station and season.
How far ahead can I book the shinkansen and the KTX?
Reserved shinkansen seats go on sale one month ahead at 10:00, and JR Central’s smart EX takes requests up to a year ahead. KORAIL opens KTX bookings one month ahead at 07:00.
Does Japan need an electronic travel authorisation?
Not yet. Japan’s Immigration Services Agency says JESTA is aimed for introduction during fiscal year 2028.
Which palace or castle is open on a Tuesday?
Gyeongbokgung closes on Tuesdays. At Nijo-jo, the castle grounds and the Ninomaru-goten Palace were open on the Wednesday and Thursday of our plan; the Ninomaru-goten Palace is closed on Tuesdays in December and from 26 December to 3 January.
Sources
- Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, visa exemptions; visa requirements; Immigration Services Agency, JESTA (PDF, Japanese)
- K-ETA eligible countries; K-ETA exemption extension notice; K-ETA age exemption; Korea Tourism Organization, entry guidance; Korean Embassy visa-waiver table
- JR Central westbound timetable from 14 March 2026 (PDF); JR Central fares (PDF); oversized baggage; JR West HARUKA timetable (PDF)
- KORAIL timetables (KTX timetable as of 1 November 2026); KORAIL fare notice; AREX Express; Seoul subway fares; Busan Metro fares; Busan–Gimhae Light Rail fares and transfer rule (Korean)
- Keikyu from Haneda; Kyoto City Subway fares
- Nijo-jo Castle admission; Gyeongbokgung admission
- Federal Reserve H.10 exchange rates; Tokyo accommodation tax (Japanese)
- Toyoko Inn; APA Hotel Shinagawa Sengakuji Ekimae; Shinagawa Tobu Hotel access; Keikyu route search; Shinagawa Prince Hotel access
Join travelers discovering Japan's hidden side
Weekly dispatches from off-the-beaten-path Japan — spots and stories you won't find in guidebooks.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Welcome aboard!
You're in. See you in your inbox soon.



